Onionskin

Are You Smarter Than a Second Grader?

April 30, 2008 · 8 Comments




Last fall, I attended an Administrators’ Academy by Meg Ormiston titled “Blogs, Wikis and Podcasts” and was introduced to the potential of VoiceThread. I watched a sample VoiceThread, and thought, “Hm. That’s not so difficult. My youngest son could do that.”

A few weeks ago, I attended a session by Will Richardson titled “Blogs, Wikis and Podcasts”. (The business manager almost didn’t let me go to this. Because it had the same title. Hmmm!) Anyway, Will brought this online tool to light once again, and I resolved to complete the project with my youngest son that I once envisioned in Meg’s session .

Background Info: In February, we had a rare set of circumstances come together that allowed us to travel to the U.S. Virgin Islands. We were packed (virtually, at least) and ready to go when the message came back from youngest son’s school, “Please have him read every day, and have him write a Travel Journal.”

This innocent request, made by hundreds of thousands of classroom teachers to those (awfully irresponsible) parents who have the NERVE to pull their children out of school for a family vacation, actually stopped me in my tracks.

I have an “outdoor child,” one that we have affectionately called “BBB,” as in our Barefoot Backyard Boy. He spends every moment of any free time he has — outside, digging and bug-searching and planting and eagerly scanning the fences for neighborhood buddies who might have escaped their houses to their own backyards.

This child, I was certain, would be “in his element” at the beach, digging and building and holding marine life in his hands. How — I repeat, HOW — was I going to get him to spend even one waking moment with a pencil and paper in his hand when there were so many undiscovered treasures out there at the water’s edge?

On a truly impulse buy (my husband says I know no other type), I stopped into the Apple Store and picked up a Belkin recorder that would attach to any one of our iPods. I envisioned my small son running up to me on the beach and excitedly relating his tales of discovery and kingdom conquest (LOL) as I demurely pushed the “Record” button on my Belkin.

Truth be told, we did SOME recording while there, but not of the level nor quality I’d expected. However, once home, I refused to delete these audio files from my iPod, thinking that they’d be useful eventually.

Last night, I pulled up the VoiceThread into which we had uploaded our photos, and recruited youngest son to do narrations. I even played the audio files for him from my iTunes, just to get him “in the mood.” In the end, I thought he did an amazing job of composing his thoughts for each image, and overall, of telling the “story” of our trip.

However, I didn’t expect some things…

  • I had no idea that “free commentary” would be so daunting to him. My ever-verbose child INSISTED upon dictating his words to me. I keyed them into Word, and he read from there. Towards the end, improvisation and ad-libbing dominated, even with the script before him. Yet I was surprised at his “dependence” upon having it in front of him.
  • While I worked very hard to not let the “teacher” in me come out, I found it amusing and somewhat disheartening when he would “self-correct” for what was seemingly my benefit alone. Twice he recorded the “spontaneous” voice saying, “We are busy-busy bees,” (which I know to be reflective of his experiences with his kindergarten and first grade teachers) and deleted it. I worked hard to convince him to keep it because HE liked it, no matter how “trite” it felt to me.
  • I was surprised at how very aware he was of his audience. Originally, of course, the only intended audience was his teacher, and the purpose was for a grade. Once I resurrected the project from the “forgotten” pile, his audience became my Professional Learning Network (PLN). (Funny, he knows them from the Twitter screen. “Oh, she’s the one that sent you the “Bulgarian ‘Ken Lee’ YouTube link!” or “Oh, she’s the one that has the baby chicks, and she has a son my age,right?”)
  • I was even more surprised at how the awareness of this audience affected his choice of words. He knew that he was speaking, for the most part, to educators, so he threw in his own editorial about the integrity of Christopher Columbus. Yet, he also knew that there would be students in his audience, so he captured the essence of “My parents made me do this…” every now and then. (Wouldn’t want to be TOO enthusiastic about something educational and reality-based, now, would we?)
  • I was surprised at how this “child of nature” began several narrations at the end of the Voice Thread with, “This is a…” and seemed to stop there after identification purposes, despite volumes of knowledge contained in his head about that species. Oddly enough, he had more to say about the historical sites that we (evil parents) dragged him to see, unwillingly. (Justice. Grin.)
  • Finally, I was surprised that he was adamant that his classmates should not see this. He didn’t mind “creating his digital presence,” as Steve Dembo promotes. However, he didn’t have any interest in having his current peers comment on the current product. He actually begged me to swear his teacher to secrecy and not share this with his classmates.

As always, I learn every time that I work with kids and technology. This time, the lessons were more esoteric. Now why wouldn’t I have expected that from this child?

Categories: Digital Footprint · Ed 2.0 Tools · Publishing Tools · VoiceThread

Create a free edublog to get your own comment avatar (and more!)



8 responses so far ↓

  •   Luke // May 1st 2008 at 6:52 am

    “Please have him read every day, and have him write a Travel Journal.”
    From a strictly technological viewpoint, your solution to the assignment was terrific. Engaging activities that needn’t be intrusive on family time. It may be off-topic, but my issue is with teachers who automatically insist that students work on “school stuff” when they are ill or on a family vacation.
    If a child is ill, the last thing they need to worry about is school and the last thing a teacher should be worrying about is having an equal number of assignments from every student. Most homework is review and reinforcement anyway, few, if any new concepts or skills are introduced in home work, so let them rest and recover.
    Vacations are family time, not teacher time. Reading and/or journaling may certainly be raised as an option, but in my opinion, family comes first.
    During my 33 years in the classroom, I’ve surprised many a parent by telling them there’s no assignment, just tell (insert name here) to feel better/ have a great trip, whichever applied at the time.
    And that’s my two cents worth!

  •   Tracy Murdach // May 1st 2008 at 9:32 am

    K-,
    I could relate to all you mentioned in your post. We are living parallel lives it seems. The innocence yet, “maturity” in some sense of the word in my 8 year-old amazes me; like you seem to be experiencing as well.

    Working in a K-2 environment, I forget that sometimes these children have had many experiences that were not yet a part of my childhood at that point. Is is to early to expose our children to the global world? Is it not early enough? We want our children to be aware of the world but not to have the innocence taken away.

    I loved that your son didn’t want his friends to see his voicethread and that he made you promise to not expose his secret….so 8 year old, isn’t that. Soon enough he will want his digital presence known to his friends…that will open up a whole new set of issues now, won’t it?

    -T

  •   kmulford // May 1st 2008 at 10:08 am

    Luke: Funny, I had the same response to parents when I was a classroom teacher. Occasionally, parents (usually the same ones who wanted more drill sheets assigned) would become indignant if the activity was more engaging or experiential and there was no replacement for being a part of the activity.

    Tracy: I have to admit that I was one of those parents that filled out the district permission forms and specified that photos were not to be put on the internet. But after reading some of the info in the Pew internet Report and hearing some of the current ed tech leaders speak, I’ve come around to the point where I no longer want someone else managing my sons’ digital footprint – I want to do that until they’re old enough to make their own decisions about how to manage it to their benefit. So, yes, it’s so VERY eight to not want your classmates to see it. But you should have seen his eyes light up when he got the VoiceThread comment from his school librarian, whom he hasn’t seen since she retired!

  •   teach42 // May 2nd 2008 at 7:46 am

    LoL, as public as I think most people are learning to be, there’s still a time and place for privacy. Nothing wrong with that. Great stuff tho. And for the record, let him know that Steve from the Discovery Channel thinks his travelogue is fantastic! And I’ve worked with the Travel Channel several times now, so I should know!

  •   H Langlois // May 4th 2008 at 7:15 am

    I read your blog before watching the travelogue, and while the project is really great in and of itself, think I enjoyed it even more because of the behind-the-scenes, “the making of” info you give in the blog. (It’d be neat if there was some way to add that to the travelogue as an optional link — maybe you can suggest that to the folks at VoiceThread?)

    In any case, he DID do a great job, and you’re right — you very effectively proved the point that “my youngest son could do that.” I’m always impressed with the ways you integrate technology into learning (and incidentally, so are my kids — they think you’re the coolest mom in the world). But I especially like the fact that you shared what YOU learned from the experience.

  •   kmulford // May 4th 2008 at 10:40 pm

    Steve: I shared your comment with him. His reaction? “You mean I could actually get PAID to do travel documentaries when I grow up?” LOL.

    H Langlois: Interesting idea, sharing the “process” with the VoiceThread people. Thanks again for stopping by to comment. Of course, my kids think YOU are the coolest mom in the world. We should trade.

  •   Paul Bogush // Jan 20th 2009 at 8:33 pm

    So how did you get Steve Dembo to comment on your very first blog post ever!

  •   kmulford // Jan 20th 2009 at 10:03 pm

    Same way I got YOU to comment… I asked my PLN to have a look.

    Thanks for being here! I LOVE your blog!!!

Leave a Comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture.
Anti-Spam Image